Skip to main content

3 Things to Consider: The Osteens and Prosperity Gospel


Ok, so there's been a lot of hullabaloo surrounding the Osteen Empire following the viral spread of a video showing Victoria Osteen putting on a clinic of how to insert your foot into your mouth.  Of course, the theological landscape has been ablaze with blogs, articles, and status updates decrying the Osteens as "heretics," "liars," and "probably responsible for all the world's problems."  Okay, maybe that last one is a bit of an overreaction...

This got me to thinking, and there's a few things I'd like to address in light of "Happy-gate 2014."

1. This is nothing new for the Osteens.

I can only assume from the reactions I've seen that some people have simply never heard of the Osteens before, or if they had heard of them, they have never bothered to look into their theology (or lack thereof) or their practices. If they had bothered to investigate them, if only briefly, they would know that this kind of message is business-as-usual for the Gospel-according-to-Osteen. A quick glance at his page on Amazon shows that the words "You" or "Your" appear 15 times in the titles of his top-12 best-selling books, while the word "God" appears once, as does "Bible," while "Jesus" and/or "Christ" are completely absent. What does this tell me? That Joel and Victoria are much more interested in "you" getting to know more about "you" than they are interested in God. In the Gospel according to Osteen, life is all about "you," so why shouldn't worship also be? Cue my lack of surprise when I saw the video diminishing God's importance in the act of worship.

2. Prosperity Gospel works for a reason.

Well, actually two reasons. 1) It is the natural evolution of theology in an American culture that has become completely self-obsessed. Turn on daytime TV one day or look at the cover of a magazine and tell me I'm wrong.  Everything is about "How to lose those 5 pesky pounds" or "How to go from poor to powerful," so why wouldn't churches try to follow suit?  The Osteens have tapped into the reality that most people really aren't that interested in anything outside themselves, and they've managed to turn selfishness into a religion. Instead of living the difficult life of a disciple of Christ, you can follow 3 easy steps and begin the waterfall of blessings from God. Who doesn't want that?! This attracts a lot of people, but it's not the only reason Prosperity Gospel is thriving.

The other reason I see is 2) For the millions of persons living in poverty in America, false hope is better than no hope. Now, I'm not saying the Prosperity Gospel is good for those in poverty, in fact I think it's incredibly harmful, but I am saying if you are in poverty, the Prosperity Gospel is an easy sell. "If you pray a little more, go to church a little more, and (most importantly) give a little more, God will grant you blessings like you've never known." And when those blessings don't come? "Don't lose faith now, the blessings are right around the corner, just keep praying, attending, and giving."

3. We can learn something.

The Prosperity Gospel drives my ministry friends crazy, and it makes me furious, to be sure. But then I have to wonder, what are we, the mainline & evangelical churches, saying to the millions in poverty and the millions more who hate themselves and the lives they live? What truth are we proclaiming? What hope are we offering? Because clearly people are hungry for hope, thirsty for something to help them get through their difficult days, and I can't shake the feeling that Prosperity Gospel works, in part, because mainline & evangelical churches remain largely silent on the subjects of poverty, depression, and self-loathing. While it might be easier for me to simply throw stones at the Osteen empire, the more challenging and ultimately life-giving response would be to look critically at my own ministry and ask the difficult questions. The reality is, you can be a church that focuses on God, but ignores the difficult realities of life.  You can be a pastor that offers theologically-sound teaching, but not hope to hopeless. The Gospel is, has, and always will be the Good News that asks us to "take up your cross," yet also to "take heart." We must be willing to offer Gospel-centered responses to those things that occupy the lives of so many. We, myself included, cannot speak out against Victoria Osteen if we are not also willing to speak out on the subjects that matter most to our communities.


Even if it lands us on YouTube.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

On Uniting Methodists: A "Fixed and Free" Romans 14 Church

This past week, the local church I serve, Lovers Lane UMC, hosted a gathering of area clergy and lay leaders interested in learning more about a movement called "Uniting Methodists." Leading the presentation and ensuing discussion were Rev. Rachel Baughman of Oak Lawn UMC in Dallas, and Rev. Dr. Stan Copeland of Lovers Lane.

I respect both of these leaders immensely; Rachel was actually my children's pastor when I was in the 6th grade at W.C. Martin UMC in Bedford, TX, and Stan has been my boss and mentor for the better part of the last decade. That respect was shared by the room as far as I could tell, and it was their presence together on stage that likely sparked more than a little curiosity amongst those who came. 

The sight of them sitting together on stage perhaps sums up Uniting Methodists in one image. On the left (literally and figuratively), a young, progressive, woman with clerical collar, black plastic glasses, and dreads pulled neatly into a bun. On the righ…

A Little Ice, A Lot of Water, A Whole Heap of Cynicism

Scott here.  I've seen a lot of concern over the wasting of water in the now infamous ALS Ice Bucket Challenge.  If you don't know what that is, welcome to the internet, you must be new here.  Google it and come back, we'll wait.

Anyways, I've seen figures suggesting that around 1.2 million Americans have participated in the Challenge, using approx. 5 gallons of water each, meaning somewhere in the ballpark of 6 million gallons of water have been used so far (as of two days ago, so that number has grown).  Sounds like a staggering number, and it is a significant amount of water, to be sure.   And if you donated to ALSA, but chose to forgo the ice bucket to conserve water, I think that is admirable, and I applaud your decision to use the Challenge as a way to shed light on water scarcity at the same time.

But before we begin criticizing an effective fundraising practice by lamenting the waste of water, I wonder if we are willing to examine our own daily practices and c…

Why I Loved Daniel and Hated Job

I used to hate the book of Job.

There, I said it.  I know some of you might be in shock that I--a seminarian, a pastor, a future ordained elder--would actually hate a book of the Bible.  But it's true, for the longest time I just could not stand the story of a man whose life get's worse and worse and worse, simply because God wanted to prove something to Satan... or something like that.*

Which is funny because my wife absolutely loves the book of Job.  It's her favorite in the entire Old Testament, and I could not understand why for the longest time.  It's just so dadgum depressing.  A man's life starts out so wonderful, so full of blessing and grace, and slowly falls apart until nothing is left but his faith.  And I know, I know, at the end he gets back double what he had before, but that's a few verses at the end of chapters and chapters of misery.

Not like Daniel.  The story of Daniel is a book that starts out with destruction and judgement and nothing but …